1822 to 1832               William W. McIntosh, Appointed by Governor Jonathan Jennings

March to April 1832   George Secrest 

April 1832 until 1834  James Mosler

 

Following dates are November to November, generally 2 year terms.

1834 to 1836               Fielding Priest 

1836 to 1840               David Rudisull

1840 to  1844              Edward R. Kercheval

1844 to  1848              Archibald Johnson

1848 to  1852              Joseph Collier 1848 to1852

1852 to  1854              Joseph Siddons 

1854 to  1856              Anderson Johnson

1856 to  1858              William L. Farrow 

1858 to  1860              John R. Mahan 

1860 to  1862              William S. Collier 

1862 to 1864               John McKee 

1864 to 1866               Green Burrow

1866 to1867                John S. Applegate – died in office

1867 to 1868               Levi Woodrum – filled Applegate’s term

1868 to 1872               George W. Sherrill

1872 to 1876               James Stone

1876 to 1880               Moses T. Lewman

1880 to 1884               James Brandon

1884 to 1888               Leander L. Lewis

1888 to 1892               William B. Vestal

1892 to 1896               Francis M. Glidewell

1896 to 1900               Richard Bunten

1900 to 1904               John F. Cooper

1904 to 1908               David Maze

 

The following dates are January 1st to January 1st, beginnings of occasional 2 consecutive 2-year terms, and chief deputies becoming the next sheriff.

1908 to 1912               Frank M. StroubeS

1912 to 1916               Theodore Boez  

1916 to 1920               Howard Harris

1920 to 1922               Lawrence Sears – until his death in September 1922.

Sept to Nov 1922        Jacob McCurry acting sheriff

Nov to Dec 1922         Glenn Stringer acting sheriff

1922 to 1926               Leslie Sears – elected in November 1922

1926 to 1930               Edward H. Eiteljorg – resigned Sept 1930 to become Greencastle Twp. Trustee

1930 to 1934               Alva Bryan

1934 to 1938               John Sutherlin

1938 to Feb 1941        Lawrence Graham

1941 to 1942               Robert D. Patton

1942 to 1946               Paul Grimes

1946 to 1948               James McDonald

1948 to 1958               Joseph G. Rollings

1958 to 1966               Kenneth Knauer

1966 to 1974               Bob Albright

1974 to 1982               James Baugh

1982 to 1990               Garry Hoffa

1990 to 1998               Richard Lyon

1998 to 2000               Tom Helmer

2000 to 2008               Mark Frisbie  resigned Aug. 2008

2008 to 2014               Steve Fenwick  appointed, Sept. 2008, elected in 2010

2014 to 2022               Scott Stockton   resigned December 2022

2022 to 2022               Matt Demings  acting sheriff until Jan 1

2022 to Present           Jerrod Baugh